The rising popularity of audiobooks

My main focus on this site is to discuss research about the use of audiobooks for education, but I found this article in The Guardian from last November both interesting from the point of view of what it’s like to be a narrator and the astonishing rise in popularity of audiobooks.

So it’s not just me who loves them? Apparently not, according to this Guardian article, the audiobook market in the UK last year increased 43% compared to the previous year, while physical book sales dropped by about 5%. The figures from the US also show an approximate 25% rise in audiobook sales according to the latest Audio Publishers Association survey of 2018 and this is mostly digital downloads from Audible.

Deloitte predicts the US audiobook market to keep increasing at a rate of 20-25% per year, partially because audiobooks are cheaper to produce and distribute than print books, so more titles will keep being added: “The cost of producing an audiobook is not negligible, but it is quite small compared to the cost of advances, promotion, and printing for traditional books, so we expect the percentage of titles that are made into audiobooks to rise over time.”

As Michelle Cobb from the Audio Publishers Association says, “The bottom line is that listeners like great stories read by great narrators, and our members continue to produce the quality listening experiences that consumers crave. Those consumers, in turn, reward us with listening to more of it and enticing other people to listen. It’s a cycle of appreciation and growth that all can enjoy.”

I’m so glad it’s not just me then.

Exploring the Influence of Audiobooks on Adolescent Readers’ Motivation and Reading Comprehension (Knutson, 2019)

This recently published article in the Illinois Reading Council Journal by Tom Knutson describes a small action research project involving participants who used audiobooks remedially. The author conducted a four-week action research project with his middle school remedial reading summer classes. He found that the five participants who listened to audiobooks, during independent reading time, were more motivated to listen to audiobooks than read the text alone and that listening to the audio versions improved students’ understanding of the stories.

Unfortunately, this author repeats the misconception that “a growing body of research has suggested that audiobooks can help students in several critical areas of the reading process (Beers, 1998; Chang, 2011; Esteves & Whitten, 2011; Milani, Lorusso, & Molteni, 2010; Whittingham et al., 2013; Wolfson, 2008)” (Knutson, 2019, p. 4) and all of these references are addressed in my dissertation (Toms, 2016) except for Chang (2011).

Chang (2011) studied 7 teenage EFL learners who read while they listened (RWL) to audio CD versions of graded readers and found that dictation scores increased and so did scores on vocabulary tests, as compared to a control group of students. It is interesting that “the researcher had to constantly remind [the participants] that they must listen to the CDs and that listening was their focus for fear they would just read and ignore the aural input” (Chang, 2011, p. 49) because, as explained in Toms (2016, Section 2.3), it is difficult to guarantee that a reader is actually tracking the same word to which they are listening. Another interesting point was made that “4 students dropped out [of the study] within a week because they considered the intervention very difficult and they preferred the formal instruction” (Chang, 2011, p. 49) which implies that RWL is not appealing to everyone. Knutson (2019, p. 16) advises that, forcing students to read while listening “can turn them away from audiobooks.”

Knutson’s (2019) participants made an interesting observation that listening to audiobooks eliminated “outside stimuli that was distracting” (p. 12) compared to reading a book in a classroom. The author found that the participants developed an “excitement toward reading” (p. 12) by listening to audiobooks of their own choice and this was evident in his conferences with the students. Knutson presents convincing evidence from conversations with participants that they thoroughly comprehended the story when they listened to the professionally narrated audiobook. The author concludes with the observation that this study “suggested that audiobooks did not change students’ negative perceptions toward written work and book discussion with peers” (p. 13) and that participants said they would prefer to keep listening to audiobooks than to write about their reading.

As always with this under-researched topic, I agree with Knutson (2019) that “more research is needed” (p. 15).

References

Chang, A. C. (2011). The effect of reading while listening to audiobooks: Listening fluency and vocabulary gain. Asian Journal of English Language Teaching, 21, 2143-2164

Knutson, T. (2019). Exploring the Influence of Audiobooks on Adolescent Readers’ Motivation and Reading Comprehension. Illinois Reading Council Journal, 47(4), 3–18.

Toms, S. J. (2016). Listening to the library: Preadolescent student perceptions of the impact of downloadable audiobooks on their literacy development. Available from: https://rune.une.edu.au/web/handle/1959.11/21654

 

 

 

Misleading infographic about audiobooks

This infographic has been reused for many years but is unfortunately misleading. At first glance, it seems convincing that the Audio Publishers Association (APA) has provided a bibliography of sources but, as is too often the case, we don’t really check whether the sources are accurately portrayed in the image. I write about this same infographic in my dissertation (Toms, 2016) based on a bibliography from 2016. As explained in Toms (2016, p. 39), there is no evidence in the bibliography that listening to audiobooks ‘increases reading accuracy by 52%,’ ‘improves comprehension by 76%,’ ‘increases motivation by 67%’ and when you think about it, statistics like that are not very meaningful as reading accuracy, comprehension and motivation are extremely hard to measure convincingly in a quantitative way. What age group is it referring to? Fluent readers and writers? I challenge you to go through the bibliography and find the source of the data.

There is one very interesting addition to the 2019 bibliography that was not in the 2016 version: Deniz, et al (2019) found that fMRI scans of brain activity were similar whether participants read the text or listened to a narration of the same story. This supports the study (Michael et al., 2001) quoted in my dissertation (Toms, 2016, p. 29) where I explain that it was the complexity of language that determined brain activation rather than the modality of input (reading or listening).

 

References

Deniz, F., Nunez-Elizalde, A. O., Huth, A. G., Gallant, J. L. (2019). The Representation of Semantic Information Across Human Cerebral Cortex During Listening Versus Reading Is Invariant to Stimulus Modality. Journal of Neuroscience, 39(39), 7722-7736. Available from: https://www.jneurosci.org/content/39/39/7722

Michael, E. B., Keller, T. A., Carpenter, P. A. & Just, M. A. (2001). fMRI Investigation of Sentence Comprehension by Eye and Ear: Modality Fingerprints on Cognitive Processes. Human Brain Mapping, 13(4), 239–252.

Toms, S. J. (2016). Listening to the library: Preadolescent student perceptions of the impact of downloadable audiobooks on their literacy development. Available from: https://rune.une.edu.au/web/handle/1959.11/21654

E-books and audiobooks: Extending the digital experience by Larson (2015)

Larson’s observation of a class of sixth graders (26 students), which the author visited 17 times in 5 weeks, involved the students using three audiobook/ebook combinations on Kindle Fires. The author explains that they used the “addition of professional narration during which a voice recording, or audiobook, is synchronized with an e-book text” (p. 169). The author argues that literacy instruction should include emerging technologies, such as professional narration that syncs with digital text.

It is disappointing that Larson (p. 170) repeats the unsupported belief that “The benefit of audiobooks is similar to that of reading aloud, and research supports the use of audiobooks to strengthen literacy development (Beers, 1998; Grover & Hannegan, 2012; Moyer, 2012; Wolfson, 2008)” which I have refuted in detail in my dissertation (Toms, 2016).

Larson (p. 170) claims that “Audiobooks model effective read-aloud attributes, which can be particularly beneficial if the listener is reading along (Gander, 2013)” but there is no guarantee that students are actually tracking the text simultaneously while listening to the audio (Toms, 2016). Gander (2013) provides an enthusiastic opinion article about the value of listening to YA audiobooks.

For the audiobook part of the study, Larson’s findings were similar to my own research (Toms, 2016) in the following two areas: Students’ preference for different narrator styles and the enthusiasm of students to listen to the narration (as one student said, “I didn’t want to turn off the book!” p. 174). The bulk of observations were around the advantages that students found when reading the digital version of the text on a Kindle Fire.

 

References

Gander, L. (2013). Audiobooks: The greatest asset in the library. Library Media Connection, 31(4), 48.

Larson, L.C. (2015). E-books and audiobooks: Extending the digital experience. The Reading Teacher 69(2). 169-177.

Toms, S. J. (2016). Listening to the library: Preadolescent student perceptions of the impact of downloadable audiobooks on their literacy development. Available from: https://rune.une.edu.au/web/handle/1959.11/21654

 

Embracing Audiobooks as an Effective Educational Tool by Stacy Waite

This interesting 2018 Masters’ thesis by Stacy Waite is a welcome addition to the discussion about audiobooks. The author reviewed numerous articles about the educational use of audiobooks and the perceived stigma that audiobook listening is not really reading, provides statistical use of audiobooks, conducted a survey of adult book club audiobook listeners and provides middle school English lesson plans incorporating the use of audiobooks.

I was interested to read about her claim on page 8 that there is “plenty of well-documented research to support the benefits of audiobooks (Larson, 2015; Serafini, 2009; Willingham, 2016).” Serafini (2009) appears to be a reprint of his 2004 article referred to in my dissertation (Toms, 2016) and Willingham (2016) is a well-expressed opinion piece objecting to the question of whether audiobook listening is ‘cheating.’ Unfortunately, neither article can be put in the category of “well-documented research.” Larson (2015) is indeed a study of 26 sixth graders using audio/ebook combinations of books on Kindle Fires. This study will be reviewed in the next blog post.

Waite claims that audiobooks could be “implemented in the classroom to bridge the gaps” (p. 6), and later explains, “One tool that could be implemented in the classroom to bridge the gaps is the use of audiobooks” (p. 7). It appears then that the focus of the use of audiobooks in this dissertation is as a remedial tool for struggling readers. Again the author states, “Students who are struggling in literacy should have access to any available tools and techniques that can help them bridge that gap” (p. 9).

Unfortunately, Waite falls into the trap of likening audiobook listening to parents reading aloud to children, which I have refuted in my dissertation (Toms, 2016). Learning styles are also referred to, for example saying that audiobooks would be beneficial for students who are “auditory learners” (p. 10), but learning styles theory has been discredited by Willingham (2009). Waite (p. 34) later concedes this but provides a ‘learning styles questionaire’ as part of a middle school English lesson plan for teachers.

Waite concludes that if audiobooks are “used the right way, people of all ages
can experience literature at just about any complexity level, introducing them to books that they would have never chosen independently” (p. 42). Substantial research about the educational use of audiobooks remains elusive.

References

Larson, L.C. (2015). E-books and audiobooks: Extending the digital experience. The Reading Teacher 69(2). 169-177.

Serafini, F. (2009). Audiobooks and literacy: An educator’s guide to utilizing audiobooks in the classroom. RHI: Reaching Reluctant Readers, 1(1), 90-91. Reprint of 2004 article.

Toms, S. J. (2016). Listening to the library: Preadolescent student perceptions of the impact of downloadable audiobooks on their literacy development. Available from: https://rune.une.edu.au/web/handle/1959.11/21654

Waite, S. (2018). Embracing Audiobooks as an Effective Educational Tool. Education and Human Development Master’s Theses. Available from: https://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/ehd_theses/1218

Willingham, D. T. (2009). Why don’t students like school? San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Willingham, D. (2016, July 24). Is listening to an audio book cheating? Daniel Willingham- Science and Education. Retrieved from http://www.danielwillingham.com/daniel-willingham-science-andeducation-blog/is-listening-to-an-audio-book-cheating

 

 

 

Elusive audiobook research

There are numerous publications that claim there is plenty of research about audiobooks in education (e.g. Wolfson 2008; Grover and Hannegan 2005, 2012; Burkey 2013) but after delving into the source research I found that most of what is called research is either opinion articles or research done decades ago about parents reading aloud to their pre-reader children (e.g. Anderson, et al.1985, is based on reading research conducted in the 1960s and 70s). The limited research that is available about audiobooks in education is either about using them remedially or to assist students learning English. The experience of fluent students who listen to professionally narrated audiobooks on their personal devices seems not to have been studied. Research involving responsive reader-listener relationships cannot be applied to audiobook listening. An adult interacting with a young child while reading, discussing the illustrations or storyline together, is nothing like what is experienced when listening to a professionally narrated audiobook that can be paused or listened to repeatedly. Unfortunately, “research on audiobooks is rare” (Have and Pedersen 2016, 5) and “the vast majority of articles and studies of audiobooks with young people is largely anecdotal and not of a scholarly nature” (Brock 2013, 24).

Works cited:

Anderson, R., Hiebert, E., Scott, J. & Wilkinson, I. Becoming a nation of readers: The Report on the Commission on Reading. National Institute of Education, 1985.

Brock, R. M. Audiobooks and attitudes: An examination of school librarians’ perspectives. UMI Microform 3598459, ProQuest LLC, 2013.

Grover, S. & Hannegan, L. D. “Not Just for Listening: Integrating Audiobooks into the Curriculum.” Book Links 14, no. 5 (2005): 16.

Grover, S. & Hannegan, L. D. Listening to learn: Audiobooks supporting literacy. American Library Association, 2012.

Have, I. & Pedersen, B. S. Digital Audiobooks: New Media, Users, and Experiences. Taylor & Francis, 2016.

Wolfson, G. “Using audiobooks to meet the needs of adolescent readers.” American Secondary Education 36, no. 2 (2008): 105-114.

Tales2go and WestEd study

I recently requested a copy of a 2016 study about audiobooks distributed by Tales2go. The study is entitled ‘How Listening Drives Improvement in Vocabulary and Reading Comprehension.’ The Tales2go professional development coordinator explained in the accompanying email that, “The study was designed to determine the effect of adding a listening component to literacy instruction, specifically the impact on student vocabulary, reading comprehension and motivation to read.”

Tales2go contracted WestEd to conduct the study and the resulting report is essentially a marketing brochure for Tales2go. The study tested grade 2 and 3 students, who attended an after-school program for a minimum of three days per week in the San Francisco Bay area, in the areas of reading comprehension, vocabulary and reading motivation. “In second grade, 65 and 62 students were randomized to the Treatment and Control conditions respectively. In third grade, 41 and 46 students were randomized to the Treatment and Control conditions respectively” (p. 10). The study found test score increases in all three areas for the students who listened to Tales2go, compared to students who did not have access to Tales2go. As noted in the abstract of the linked study, “While not statistically significant, due to a limited sample size, the study effects were educationally meaningful and consistently positive across all measures” (p. 1).

Tales2go prides itself as a model that provides simultaneous streaming access to children’s audiobooks and the program delivery proved reliable during the study period. Participants listened for an average of about 600 minutes to Tales2go during the entire study of 8-10 weeks.

Clearly, this was a limited study that was funded by an audiobook vendor to promote their product.

 

Audiobooks for youth: A practical guide to sound literature by Burkey (2013)

Burkey, M. (2013). Audiobooks for youth: A practical guide to sound literature. Chicago, IL: American Library Association. 120 pages, $54.66, ISBN 9780838911570

This publication provides a detailed history of the development of audiobook technology in the United States. The author states that there is “substantial evidence about the benefits of using audiobooks in education” (p. 17) but provides very thin evidence of this. This book does not include credible studies about non-remedial use of audiobooks by children but instead uses research first published in the 1960s and 70s showing the benefits of parents reading aloud to pre-reader children. This dated research is not relevant to modern audiobook listening.

Listening to learn: Audiobooks supporting literacy (2012) by Grover & Hannegan.

Grover, S. & Hannegan, L. D. (2012). Listening to learn: Audiobooks supporting literacy. Chicago, IL: American Library Association. 208 pages, $66.16, ISBN 9780838911075

This book repeatedly says there “has been a great deal of research supporting the use of audiobooks to promote vocabulary development, fluency and comprehension” (p. 10).

HOWEVER …

Just after citing this book Brock (2013, p. 1) states that there is a “small body of existing audiobook research” and later confirms, “the vast majority of articles and studies of audiobooks with young people is largely anecdotal and not of a scholarly nature” (p. 24).

Brock, R. M. (2013). Audiobooks and attitudes: An examination of school librarians’ perspectives. UMI Microform 3598459, Ann Arbor, MI: ProQuest LLC (Reviewed HERE).