This interesting 2018 Masters’ thesis by Stacy Waite is a welcome addition to the discussion about audiobooks. The author reviewed numerous articles about the educational use of audiobooks and the perceived stigma that audiobook listening is not really reading, provides statistical use of audiobooks, conducted a survey of adult book club audiobook listeners and provides middle school English lesson plans incorporating the use of audiobooks.
I was interested to read about her claim on page 8 that there is “plenty of well-documented research to support the benefits of audiobooks (Larson, 2015; Serafini, 2009; Willingham, 2016).” Serafini (2009) appears to be a reprint of his 2004 article referred to in my dissertation (Toms, 2016) and Willingham (2016) is a well-expressed opinion piece objecting to the question of whether audiobook listening is ‘cheating.’ Unfortunately, neither article can be put in the category of “well-documented research.” Larson (2015) is indeed a study of 26 sixth graders using audio/ebook combinations of books on Kindle Fires. This study will be reviewed in the next blog post.
Waite claims that audiobooks could be “implemented in the classroom to bridge the gaps” (p. 6), and later explains, “One tool that could be implemented in the classroom to bridge the gaps is the use of audiobooks” (p. 7). It appears then that the focus of the use of audiobooks in this dissertation is as a remedial tool for struggling readers. Again the author states, “Students who are struggling in literacy should have access to any available tools and techniques that can help them bridge that gap” (p. 9).
Unfortunately, Waite falls into the trap of likening audiobook listening to parents reading aloud to children, which I have refuted in my dissertation (Toms, 2016). Learning styles are also referred to, for example saying that audiobooks would be beneficial for students who are “auditory learners” (p. 10), but learning styles theory has been discredited by Willingham (2009). Waite (p. 34) later concedes this but provides a ‘learning styles questionaire’ as part of a middle school English lesson plan for teachers.
Waite concludes that if audiobooks are “used the right way, people of all ages
can experience literature at just about any complexity level, introducing them to books that they would have never chosen independently” (p. 42). Substantial research about the educational use of audiobooks remains elusive.
References
Larson, L.C. (2015). E-books and audiobooks: Extending the digital experience. The Reading Teacher 69(2). 169-177.
Serafini, F. (2009). Audiobooks and literacy: An educator’s guide to utilizing audiobooks in the classroom. RHI: Reaching Reluctant Readers, 1(1), 90-91. Reprint of 2004 article.
Toms, S. J. (2016). Listening to the library: Preadolescent student perceptions of the impact of downloadable audiobooks on their literacy development. Available from: https://rune.une.edu.au/web/handle/1959.11/21654
Waite, S. (2018). Embracing Audiobooks as an Effective Educational Tool. Education and Human Development Master’s Theses. Available from: https://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/ehd_theses/1218
Willingham, D. T. (2009). Why don’t students like school? San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Willingham, D. (2016, July 24). Is listening to an audio book cheating? Daniel Willingham- Science and Education. Retrieved from http://www.danielwillingham.com/daniel-willingham-science-andeducation-blog/is-listening-to-an-audio-book-cheating